Looking for answers? Every question is welcome here.

Thursday, 5 January 2023

Roman Catholicism and the Reformation: Why We Still Disagree

There are very many genuine Christians in the Catholic Church. We rejoice in that, and nothing here is said to question their sincerity or their love for Jesus. This article is about teaching, not about people: where we believe some official Catholic teaching differs from the gospel of the Bible, and why we think that matters.

An old question

This is not a new question. In the early church, some Christians were told that they must be circumcised to be saved. Paul confronted Peter over it, because adding a requirement to Christ's finished work was contrary to the gospel (Galatians 2:11-16). Peter and the others accepted the correction.

In every generation since, faithful Christians have had to ask the same thing: is the gospel pure, or has something been added to it? Augustine, the Waldensians, John Wycliffe, Jan Hus and Martin Luther, among others, pressed that question, sometimes at great cost. They held that the true Church is the whole people of God, and not an institution that claims Christ's authority for itself.

What we believe the Bible teaches

When we repent and trust in what Jesus has done, taking on himself the punishment we deserve, we pass from death to life. We are born again by God's Spirit, and the Bible says nothing can separate us from God's love in Christ (Romans 8:38-39). Salvation is by grace alone, through faith alone, in Christ alone. Good works flow from genuine faith as its fruit, such as "love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, self-control" (Galatians 5:22-23, ESV), but they do not save us. They show that God's Spirit is at work in us.

Where we respectfully differ

As we understand official Catholic teaching, a person is justified through baptism and the other sacraments, and a mortal sin separates a person from God's grace until it is confessed to a priest and absolved (Catechism of the Catholic Church, paragraphs 1855 to 1861 and 1446). Penance, attendance at Mass and set prayers are part of that life of grace. We believe this adds to the finished work of Christ and takes away the assurance that the Bible offers.

Catholic teaching also holds that Sacred Tradition stands alongside Scripture, with equal reverence (paragraph 82). We believe God's written Word is our only final authority in matters of life and salvation, and that every tradition must be tested by it (Mark 7:6-13; Acts 17:11).

The Catholic Church has in recent decades sought closer dialogue with other Christians, and we welcome the warmth of that. But official teaching on these points has not changed, and so we think honesty requires us to say that the differences remain.

Why it matters so much

Paul cared about the gospel so deeply that he wrote:

"I am astonished that you are so quickly deserting him who called you in the grace of Christ and are turning to a different gospel... But even if we or an angel from heaven should preach to you a gospel contrary to the one we preached to you, let him be accursed." Galatians 1:6-8 (ESV)

We do not quote this against our Catholic neighbours. We quote it because it shows that the gospel is worth guarding, and that how we are saved is not a minor matter.

A sad chapter, and a hopeful one

It is a matter of historical record that church authorities in the Middle Ages and the Reformation era suppressed vernacular Bibles and persecuted Christians who held to salvation by faith alone. William Tyndale's English New Testaments were publicly burned, and Tyndale himself was put to death for translating the Bible. We mention it with sorrow, not with triumph, because Christians of every tradition have at times failed to show the love of Christ.

Yet throughout history, God has kept a people who trusted in him alone for forgiveness, without relying on anything they had done. The Bible says Abraham believed God and it was counted to him as righteousness (Genesis 15:6; Romans 4:3), and that we are called to the same kind of faith: trusting God, and all he has done in his Son, and not ourselves.

An invitation

If you are a Catholic reading this, we ask you to read Galatians and Romans with an open Bible and see for yourself. If you are a Protestant, speak with your Catholic friends with "gentleness and respect" (1 Peter 3:15, ESV).

For a longer discussion, see our companion article Roman Catholicism and the gospel: a conversation between friends, or read what we believe.